Skip to main content Skip to footer 
Mediation has become one of the go-to methods for resolving disputes in England and Wales, sitting comfortably alongside litigation and arbitration as a credible and often highly effective route to settlement.
Whether used on its own or as part of a broader strategy, it gives the parties a genuine opportunity to reach a workable agreement on their own terms. Our mediation solicitors at Tower Bridge Legal act for clients across Birmingham and London, providing strategic advice and hands-on advocacy throughout the process.
What Is Mediation?
In essence, mediation is a voluntary and confidential process in which a trained, independent mediator sits down with the parties to help them talk through the dispute, identify where they actually agree and where they differ, and work towards a resolution that both sides can live with. The mediator is not there to take sides or hand down a ruling – their job is to open up lines of communication and steer the conversation towards common ground that might not have been obvious without that third-party perspective.
If the parties do reach an agreement on the day, the terms are set out in a settlement agreement that becomes a binding contract once everyone has signed it, and if agreement proves elusive, nothing is lost. The entire process is conducted on a without-prejudice basis, which means that neither party can refer to what was said or offered during the mediation in any later court or arbitration proceedings.
Mediation and the Courts
Far from being an alternative that operates in isolation from the court system, mediation works hand in hand with litigation in practice – the Civil Procedure Rules and the associated Practice Directions on Pre-Action Conduct actively require parties to think about alternative dispute resolution (ADR), mediation included, before and during court proceedings, and judges will often encourage or even direct parties to give it a go at various stages of a case.
There are real consequences for ignoring that expectation – a party who turns down a reasonable opportunity to mediate risks an adverse costs order at the end of the case, even if they win at trial. The trend in recent years has been firmly towards greater judicial support for mediation, and there are now situations where the court has the power to compel parties to engage with the process.
The Advantages of Mediation
Cost efficiency – Pound for pound, mediation is one of the most cost-effective ways of resolving a dispute. A typical commercial mediation can be set up and concluded within a matter of weeks, the mediator’s fees are usually split between the parties, and the amount of legal preparation involved, while still important, is a fraction of what you would expect for a contested trial or a full arbitration hearing.
Speed – Unlike court proceedings, which run on timetables that are often outside the parties’ control, a mediation can be arranged at a time that works for everyone involved and frequently takes place within days of being agreed. A good many disputes settle in a single session, sometimes in just a few hours.
Confidentiality – Everything discussed during a mediation stays between the parties and the mediator, and none of it can be raised in later proceedings, which gives people the freedom to speak candidly, float ideas they would not risk putting on record, and explore concessions without worrying about how it might look if the matter does end up before a judge.
Party control – One of the most appealing features of mediation is that the parties themselves decide the terms of any deal, rather than having an outcome imposed on them, which means a settlement can be shaped around commercial realities and personal priorities in ways that the remedies available through a court or tribunal may not always allow.
Preserving relationships – Where a dispute has arisen between people who have an ongoing connection – business partners, family members, neighbouring landowners, companies within a supply chain – the collaborative nature of mediation can help them find a way through the disagreement without the damage to the relationship that a contested hearing can sometimes cause.
Flexible outcomes – Because there is no judge or arbitrator dictating terms, mediation opens up outcomes that go well beyond what any court could order, such as a renegotiated contract, restructured payment terms, a formal apology, or an agreement to continue trading on a revised basis – and the only real limit is the willingness and imagination of the parties.
What Happens During Mediation?
Preparation usually starts with each party putting together a position statement, which is a concise summary of how they see the dispute and what they are hoping to achieve, and these statements are exchanged with the other side and shared with the mediator ahead of the session so that everyone comes to the table with a working understanding of where things stand.
On the day, most mediations begin with a joint session where both sides speak directly, after which the mediator breaks into private meetings with each party in turn – testing arguments, probing for flexibility, reality-checking positions and gradually shaping proposals that might form the basis of a deal. Depending on the issues involved, the session can wrap up in a few hours or run to a full day.
Your solicitor will be alongside you throughout, advising on the legal implications of anything that is put on the table, helping you weigh up offers as they come in, and making sure that the final settlement agreement accurately captures whatever terms have been agreed.
Types of Disputes Suited to Mediation
Mediation lends itself to an extremely broad range of disagreements. Our solicitors regularly support clients through mediations involving commercial contract disputes, property and boundary rows, landlord and tenant conflicts, inheritance and probate disagreements, professional negligence claims, partnership and shareholder disputes, construction matters, and family and matrimonial issues, and the process can be used at virtually any point, whether before proceedings have been issued, midway through litigation, or on the eve of trial.
We also advise on mediation clauses in commercial contracts, which may oblige the parties to attempt mediation before taking the matter to court or referring it to arbitration, and can help you understand what those clauses actually require in practice.
FAQs About Mediation
Is mediation legally binding?
The mediation process itself is not binding, and neither party is under any obligation to agree to anything on the day but if a settlement is reached, the terms are written up in a formal agreement that becomes a legally enforceable contract once both parties have signed it, meaning that if one side later goes back on the deal, the other can take steps to enforce it through the courts.
What happens if mediation does not result in a settlement?
If the parties cannot reach agreement, the mediation simply comes to an end and everyone is free to pursue other avenues – court proceedings, arbitration, or further negotiation – and because the whole process is without prejudice, nothing said or proposed during the session can be used against either party later on. It is also worth noting that even mediations which do not produce a full settlement on the day often help narrow the issues, and it is not unusual for a deal to follow shortly afterwards.
Do I need a solicitor for mediation?
Strictly speaking, there is no legal requirement to have a solicitor with you, but in our experience it makes a significant difference to the outcome, because a solicitor can help you prepare properly beforehand, advise you in real time during negotiations, push back on proposals that are not in your interest, and make sure the settlement agreement is watertight before you put your name to it.
Can I be required to mediate?
In certain circumstances, yes if your contract includes a mediation clause, you may be bound to attempt mediation before issuing proceedings or starting an arbitration, and the courts themselves actively encourage parties to mediate as part of the litigation process, with the power in some situations to direct them to do so. Turning down a reasonable invitation to mediate can result in costs penalties at trial, which is why it is generally wise to engage with the process even if you have reservations about its prospects.
How much does mediation cost?
The cost depends on the nature of the dispute and the mediator you instruct, but as a general rule the mediator’s fee is shared equally between the parties, and each side bears its own solicitor’s costs for preparation and attendance. We are always happy to give you a clear picture of likely costs upfront so that you can make a sensible decision about whether mediation is the right step to take.
Our Approach
We take mediation seriously and never treat it as a formality. Before any session, we spend time with you going over the strengths and weak points of your case, getting clear on your priorities, and putting together a position statement that makes the most persuasive case possible to the mediator and the other side.
On the day, we bring firm advocacy and pragmatic advice, knowing when to hold the line and when to test whether a sensible compromise might actually get you a better result. And if it becomes clear that the dispute will not resolve through mediation, we will be straight with you about that and talk through what comes next, whether arbitration or court proceedings.
Get in Touch
Whether you want to resolve a dispute through mediation, need advice on responding to a mediation proposal, or are trying to work out how mediation fits alongside other options in your particular situation, our solicitors can help. Contact Tower Bridge Legal today and we will talk you through it.